Redundancy Selection Criteria in Ireland: What Employers Must Do

When an employer needs to make redundancies in Ireland, the selection of which employees are made redundant is one of the most legally sensitive parts of the process. Get it wrong and you face unfair dismissal claims regardless of whether the redundancy itself is genuine.

What Makes a Redundancy Genuine?

A genuine redundancy exists where the need for the employee to do the work diminishes or ceases — typically because of restructuring, closure, reduced workload, or automation. Redundancy used as a pretext to dismiss a particular employee is not genuine and will be treated as unfair dismissal.

The Selection Pool

Before applying selection criteria, the employer must first define the pool of employees from which redundancies will be selected. The pool should include all employees doing similar or interchangeable work. Excluding employees from the pool without objective justification is a common source of unfair dismissal claims.

Fair Selection Criteria

Common fair selection criteria include: attendance record, performance record, skills and qualifications required going forward, length of service (last in first out — though this should not be the sole criterion as it can indirectly discriminate), and disciplinary record. All criteria must be objective and consistently applied.

Criteria That Are Automatically Unfair

Selection based on pregnancy, family status, trade union membership, protected disclosure, or any of the nine equality grounds is automatically unfair and renders the dismissal automatically unfair regardless of the merits of the redundancy.

Consultation

Employees must be genuinely consulted before the redundancy decision is finalised. Consultation must be real — simply informing an employee of a decision already made is not sufficient. For collective redundancies (10 or more employees within 30 days), formal consultation obligations apply under the Protection of Employment Acts.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an employer use last in first out for redundancy in Ireland?

LIFO (last in first out) can be one element of a selection matrix but should not be the sole criterion. Used alone, it can amount to indirect age discrimination and does not account for skills and performance requirements.

How much redundancy pay is an employee entitled to in Ireland?

Statutory redundancy pay in Ireland is 2 weeks’ pay per year of service (capped at €600 per week) plus a bonus week, for employees with 2 or more years’ continuous service. An employer may pay more than the statutory minimum.

Can an employee refuse a redundancy in Ireland?

An employee can refuse a suitable alternative role offered in lieu of redundancy — but if the alternative is genuinely suitable and unreasonably refused, the employee loses their entitlement to statutory redundancy pay.


This article is for informational purposes only. Consult a solicitor at O’Grady Solicitors & Co. for advice on redundancy procedures.